• Cursive First - Reviews


    Cursive First



    Review from member crunchynerd
    Member Ranking - Somewhat Positive
    Cursive First was a new concept to me (even though it turns out to have been the traditional way to teach language prior to the 1930's), but I quickly came to agree with the reasoning behind teaching cursive first, and plan on doing that with my younger two, instead of manuscript printing first, because manuscript printing first caused all the problems described, for my daughter.


    It does assume that the parent is teaching from a religious, Biblical perspective, which is a minor annoyance easily ignored.


    Having seen how it instantly cured my daughter's trouble with reversing letters, I saw the wisdom in the method. However, I got the phonogram cards along with Cursive First (it's an option for a discount over the cost of each separately), and I have a few bones to pick with the phonograms which has led me to reconsider going on to "Spell to Write and Read" by the same author.


    In what language, for instance, is the 'ey' at the end of the word 'honey' pronounced as a short i sound? Yet on the phonogram card, 'ey' is given as having 3 pronunciations: Long E, as in key, Long I as in eye, and short i as in honey. Really? When I say 'honey', the 'ey' sounds like a long E. Similarly, the phonogram card for 'ie' gives short i as a possibility, as in 'lillies'. There must be a regional dialect in English in which one must pronounce honey as "honih" and lillies as "lillihs" but that is definitely not standard. In standard English, both words have a long E sound.


    Furthermore, the phonograms 'ti' and 'si' are given to have the pronunciation "sh" which makes sense in the cases of words ending in -tion or -sion, but in that case, why not just make 'tion' and 'sion' the phonograms, because in words like 'silly' and 'tile', si and ti are most certainly not "sh"! These are obvious mistakes which cause me to question whether I really want to continue with this series or spend any additional money on it.


    I was willing to put up with unnecessary and cutesy insertions of religious commentary for the sake of educational value regardless, but the problems with presenting "honey" as having a short i sound at the end, along with the phonograms 'ti' and 'si' instead of 'tion' and 'sion' have me wondering what else might be wrong with the series.
    Pros:


    • nice traditional cursive style
    • good background information on why cursive first is a good idea
    • very thorough description of methodology
    • unlike some cursive styles, all lowercase begin and end on the baseline, preventing confusion
    • affordable and reproducible for multiple students in the same family, so a great value


    Cons:
    • strange assumptions about pronunciation which are not correct for Standard American English
    • confusing phonograms for 'ti' and 'si', which most certainly are not always "sh" (tile and silly being examples). Why not just write them as "tion" and "sion"?
    • very long and drawn-out explanations of how to use the method in a conversational manner, where a shorter description with bullet lists would have been easier to deal with




    To submit your own review of this curriculum, click here
  • Recent Group Posts

    Freestyle mom

    Are people just joining to have groupe

    Well fuzzy tutor you seem to have it together! Check site a bit ahead of my boys. (9&4). Although maybe you just pointed out to me that I need to kick it up a notch or 12 . Wow

    Group Active homeschoolers

    Started By Freestyle mom Yesterday, 06:08 PM
    wolfejj

    Friend with HFA

    Well, so far so good. I did talk with the Mom, and we worked out that the kids would talk beforehand about what they want to do during playdates (so that expectations could be managed) and that they

    Group Nurturing Emotional Intelligence

    Started By wolfejj Yesterday, 05:26 PM
    wolfejj

    Friend with HFA

    I am curious how things are going with the friend. I hope you were able to work something out.

    Group Nurturing Emotional Intelligence

    Started By wolfejj 07-23-2014, 07:11 PM
  • Recent Blog Posts

    QueenBee

    9 months - Time flies!

    It's been over nine months since I've written a blog post. Wow. People have babies in that amount of time. My best friend and I were discussing our (very under-posted upon) blogs, and as...

    07-18-2014 04:30 PM
    h5rus

    Our School Room Reveal

    Pictures included! School Room | SecularSchooling

    06-27-2014 11:08 AM
    StudyDog Reading

    Why You Shouldn’t Teach Your Child to Read – And What Some Parents Are Doing Instead

    We all want our kids to be great readers – and we spend lots of time looking for the best resources to help them learn. But the other day, I was talking with a preschool teacher at Stanford’s...

    06-05-2014 02:06 PM
    JPASS

    Fantasy or fandom -- how obsessed are you?

    In today’s world of celebrity culture, the number of obsessions seems to grow daily (“Bieber Fever” anyone?) You may not know that one of the earliest terms used to describe an extreme fan reaction...

    06-05-2014 12:10 PM